Idea

A civic protocol for shared decisions [DEMO]

Started by demo_ada · original branch

Earlier version. You are reading version 2; go to current version 3.
Version 2 · immutable · permalinkCreate a branch from v2

Select words in the idea to question them or suggest clearer wording. Log in first to participate.

A civic protocol for shared decisions

Groups making consequential decisions should publish the question, the available evidence, and the people responsible for the final choice.

Every proposal should remain open for public comment for a period proportionate to its urgency and reversibility, with fourteen days as the default.

After deciding, the group should publish its reasoning and revisit the outcome after six months.

Enter a passage manually · Create a different branch

Idea → Challenge → Discussion → Change → Resolution

Challenges

1 open
  1. Review timing should depend on the decision Open
    revisit the outcome after six months
    Questions version 3 · 4 replies · 2 wording suggestions · by demo_mei ·
  2. A fixed waiting period fails during emergencies Resolved
    Every proposal should remain open for public comment for fourteen days before a decision is made.
    Questions version 1 · 3 replies · 1 wording suggestion · resolved in version 2 · by demo_ravi ·
  3. Responsibility is incomplete without conflicts Resolved
    the people responsible for the final choice
    Questions version 2 · 2 replies · 1 wording suggestion · resolved in version 3 · by demo_sam ·

What changed and why

Versions

Detailed history
  1. Version 3 Current
    From Responsibility is incomplete without conflicts · Material conflicts are part of the evidence needed to assess the legitimacy of a decision. · by demo_ada ·
  2. Version 2
    From A fixed waiting period fails during emergencies · This preserves a legible default while requiring shorter windows to be justified by urgency and reversibility. · by demo_ada ·
  3. Version 1
    First publication · by demo_ada ·

Different directions from shared origins

Branches

4 related

No branch is declared canonical. Anyone may take any version in a different direction.

  1. A civic protocol for shared decisions [DEMO] v3 You are here
    Original branch · maintained by demo_ada · 2 stars · 3 challenges
  2. Consent-first shared decisions [DEMO FORK] v2
    Forked from A civic protocol for shared decisions [DEMO] · version 2 · maintained by demo_mei · 1 stars · 1 challenges
  3. Rapid and reversible public decisions [DEMO FORK] v1
    Forked from A civic protocol for shared decisions [DEMO] · version 1 · maintained by demo_ravi · 1 stars · 0 challenges
  4. Neighborhood emergency decisions [DEMO NESTED FORK] v1
    Forked from Rapid and reversible public decisions [DEMO FORK] · version 1 · maintained by demo_noor · 1 stars · 0 challenges